Zoey and the other girls are in the girls lounge playing a game called Confess or Stress, where a player must either tell a secret or do a dare. Chase and Logan visit the lounge during the game, and while there, Logan gives the girls a huge teddy bear. Logan then decides to "rest" in his dorm because he is not feeling well. The next day, the girls' personal secrets are being heard all over campus, with new secrets coming out as more days pass. Soon, Zoey gets blamed by the other girls for revealing their secrets. In putting a stop to all this, Zoey, Quinn and Nicole check the bear Logan gave them, which has been in the lounge ever since, and discover it has a webcam inside it. Zoey asks Chase if he is part of this scheme, which he denies. The two become aware that Logan has been spying on the girls after looking on his laptop. To catch Logan in the act, the girls give him something to watch, which leads him to tell Dean Rivers about it. In the end, Logan gets in trouble and loses his job at Sushi Rox for faking his sick time.

Sushi Rox, one of the most popular restaurants in PCA, catches fire and hits the ground. Zoey doesn't want to go on knowing Kazu, the owner of the restaurant, is heartbroken and really loved working there. So, she puts on a People Auction, having her and her friends do various chores to help raise money for Sushi Rox.

The gang accidentally injures Dean Rivers by crashing a model airplane into him. Zoey decides to try and fix Coco with the new Dean in school.

New students attend PCA and have an opportunity to find out about their new school. The new students take turns in asking Chase and Zoey questions as they reflect on their memories during their time at PCA.