Audrey and Nathan have yet another bizarre case on their hands when a prominent member of the exclusive Haven Hunt Club is found in his car, mauled to death. It has all of the earmarks of a wolf attack and Chief of Police Wournos, who is also a member of the club, is all set to organize a hunting expedition to track and kill the animal. He reluctantly agrees to Audrey's request for 24 hours to investigate further and there are soon two other attacks, one by a bear and the other by a moose. The moose attack is most revealing since it turns out the animal was stuffed leading them to believe that supernatural causes are actually at work. Their investigation turns up two suspects: Landon Taylor, the taxidermist who stuffed the animals in the first place and Jess Minion who has a reputation for being a witch.

Audrey and Nathan investigate a series of unusual assaults on people. A man on a fishing boat has his limbs severely broken, a real estate agent is shredded, and a deck hand has his face erased. In the mean time Nathan and Jess, as well as Audrey and Duke, work on their flirting.

People at the clinic Jess works at are dying, and the surviving family members are blaming a shadow creature. Jess is attacked after she makes a discovery that could help Audrey and Nathan solve the mystery. Meanwhile, Jess and Nathan kick their relationship up a notch.