Naomi finds herself in trouble when she fails an assignment, and Ryan and Kelly bring the issue to Harry's attention, while Harry struggles with a disturbing revelation about the result of a secret tryst with Naomi's mother, Tracy, from many years ago. Meanwhile, Dixon learns more about Navid when they team up to try to pull a school prank against Palisades High. Annie meets a potential love interest in the form of drama student Ty Collins, who turns out to be the wealthiest student at West Beverly, and who spirits her away for San Francisco for the evening. Silver posts the story about Ethan's infidelity with Naomi on her Internet blog, while Adrianna continues her self-destructive slide into drugs and debauchery. Also, Ryan tries to ask Kelly out on a date, but she has to find a babysitter first for her four-year-old son, and former West Beverly alumni Brenda Walsh, now a successful Broadway and London theater director, arrives back in town to help put on a new school play.

Adrianna and her evil-witch-mother, Constance, plot a cruel revenge against Annie and the rest of the faculty at West Beverly whom they think cheated Adrianna out of her role in the school play. Debbie's boss, Antonio, offers her a job to shoot a fashion show for Nylon Magazine during Fashion Week, where Annie uses the opportunity to her advantage for a class assignment, while her father advices her to try to make amends meet with Adrianna in order to try to catch her in the act with her substance abuse. Naomi believes the upcoming fashion show could help her parents' marital problems and she plans with Ethan to try to break up her father and mistress and have her mother, Tracy, meet with Charles, but it only makes matters worse. Ty and Annie's relationship is put to the test because of Adrianna's meddling. But when Adrianna lets her guard down and reveals to Annie that she lied about hooking up with Ty to break them up, it results in Annie declaring war. Silver is pursued by Debbie's sleazy client, Tony, to work in modeling, while a jealous Dixon becomes aware about what's going on, while Navid feels like he's the 'third wheel' to Dixon and Silver's growing romance. Meanwhile, Kelly receives a phone call from Sammy's father that could change her relationship with Ryan when she's offered to move to Wyoming to join Dylan, while Brenda, with her work at West Beverly finished, plans to return to New York.