While everyone meets Ted's new crazy girlfriend, everyone recounts their stories of how they met everyone else. But the stories turn out to have several inconsistencies.
Episode rating
Cast of episode
49
36
11
3
2
- Marshall Eriksen
- Ted Mosby
- Barney Stinson
- Lily Aldrin
- Robin Scherbatsky
- Blahblah
- Alexa
- Phil
- Audrey
- Too Much Tongue Guy
- Narrator