Brandon's overprotection of Kelly after the drive-by shooter and his friend go free on a legal technicality alienates her to the point of anger. Meanwhile, Donna finally learns about Valerie's backstabbing and stealing all Donna's clients. Donna successfully plots revenge against Valerie when she sets up Cooper and Valerie on a dinner date at a fancy new restaurant where Noah also shows up after Donna anonymously sends him a message to meet Valerie there. A record executive makes a huge offer for David's band, but problems arise after Devin and his group surprises David with the racial material they plan for their debut at the After Dark. Steve continues to try to win Carly's affections by trying to help her keep her small house in order.

After parting ways with After Dark, David takes a retail job at a department store and continues to reject friendly overtures from Noah, who takes over ownership of After Dark. Meanwhile, Brandon hires Emma Bennett, an attractive young writer, for important articles at the Beverly Beat. Kelly questions the professionalism of Dr. Monahan after he makes a pass at her. Valerie lobbies Noah to let her manage the Peach Pit After Dark, much to Donna's suspicions and jealousy. Elsewhere, Steve and Carly search for time alone together, while Donna's mother disapproves of her dating Noah.