The guys tell Marshall to stay away from his new date because she has "crazy eyes," but she couldn't be any crazier than Lily after she learns that Marshall's going out on his first new date.
Episode rating
Cast of episode
65
28
4
2
1
- Lily Aldrin
- Barney Stinson
- Marshall Eriksen
- Ted Mosby
- Robin Scherbatsky
- Narrator
- Chloe
- Carl
- Guy
- Wendy
- Man
- Lauren
- Janine
- Will
- Woman in Car
- Blauman